You know, we’re at one of those interesting points in history where self-interest and idealism converge. I’ve had days and days where the stock market continued to fall and continues to fall, and the analysts express such shock. And I will admit right here that I don’t understand much of this, and I don’t think that makes me far different from most of the people hearing the news, that somehow it hasn’t seemed counterintuitive to continued to fall, because one thing I do know is that it was at such an artificially elevated level to start.
If we are in fact on ground where it’s safe to stand, we can fall and get up and fall and get up again, which most of us do every day. And, yes, I do feel that we all knew at some level, if we took a moment to think about it, that there was a huge amount of artificial altitude, elevation, inflation in this society, that housing prices were ridiculous, that stock prices were way beyond value. And we now know in fact that a lot of that was a purposely contrived illusion — in which we all happily colluded, because they were many of them pleasant illusions because we are talking about mature markets having made gains over 25 years and now reached a place where no more growth is possible.
However, when shareholders continue to demand the same kind of growth in a mature market that they experienced prior to it’s maturation, there are only two possible ways to create this illusion of growth. One is to cook the books (that was Enron’s answer), and the other is to gobble up some portion of a competitor’s market, claim it for a while — telling your stockholders that this is real growth — knowing all the while that sooner or later another competitor is going to gobble it back up from you. So you create the illusion of growth by in effect eating your young. And those were among the market illusions that all of us bought into because — why? We enjoy feeling fat and happy even if we really aren’t.
I personally know there are a lot of people working those territories who knew, not just instinctively, but factually, what was going on. There were people who actually understood the mathematics behind these bogus subprime mortgages, for example. What was it that kept those people from saying the emperor has no clothes. One is fear of what happens to whistleblowers in our institutions and our society, which is that they get marginalized at least and they lose their jobs and all future opportunities in that line of work at worst, and the other emotion of course is called greed — which is that somehow I have not only a right, but an absolute need to claim more than my share out of this, and if someone else suffers I really don’t care. Let the devil take the hindmost. Now, these have to do with the inner dynamics of a person’s life, and it truly baffles me as to why in this society we continue to think that all reality and all power in terms of what drives human affairs lies in these external objective factors like policy and institutional arrangement and money when in fact there is an equally real and powerful set of drivers of human history that reside within us in the dynamics of the human heart. Which to me is not a vague and abstract phrase or a sentimental phrase or mere metaphor; it’s actually something that you can work with, that you can discipline, that you can form, that you can focus, and you can deploy to good or bad effect in the world; at present the lesser angels have enormous power.
Posted in observation and faith